Detective Sherdil (2025) Movie: Diljit Dosanjh’s Charisma Can’t Save This Muddled Murder Mystery
Detective Sherdil, the latest offering from Bollywood’s comedy-thriller genre, brings together an impressive cast led by Diljit in the titular role of an amateur detective. Directed by Ravi and produced by AAZ Films, this attempts to blend mystery with comedy in a Budapest setting. The film features a stellar cast including Diana, Boman Irani, Chunky P, Banita, Ratna Pathak, Sumeet, and Kashmira Irani.
Set against the picturesque backdrop of Budapest, Hungary, Detective Sherdil follows the story of an unconventional detective who finds himself solving the murder of industrialist Pankaj Bhatti. The film positions itself as a comedy-mystery thriller, banking on Diljit Dosanjh’s proven comic timing to carry the narrative forward.
Plot and Storyline
The central plot revolves around the murder of Pankaj Bhatti, played by Boman Irani, a wealthy industrialist living in Budapest with his family. His household includes his wife Rajeshwari (Ratna Pathak Shah), son Angad (Sumeet Vyas), and deaf-mute daughter Shanti (Banita Sandhu). When Bhatti is found dead, Detective Sherdil is called upon to unravel the mystery.
The investigation leads through a web of family secrets, hidden motives, and multiple suspects. However, the plot suffers from too many twists that create confusion rather than enhancing the mystery. I found the story had several plot holes that undermined the overall coherence.
Cast Performance
Diljit Dosanjh delivers a competent performance as the titular detective, bringing his natural charisma and comic timing to the role. His portrayal of Sherdil showcases his ability to balance humor with serious detective work. Dosanjh manages to make his character likeable even when the script doesn’t support him well.
The supporting cast feels underutilized despite their talent. Boman Irani makes his presence felt in limited scenes, while Ratna Pathak Shah brings dignity to her role as the grieving widow. Diana Penty doesn’t get enough substantial scenes to showcase her acting prowess, which I found disappointing.
Direction and Technical Aspects
Ravi Chhabriya’s direction shows both strengths and weaknesses. He manages to keep the narrative from becoming overly confusing despite multiple characters and time shifts. His use of the Budapest location is visually appealing and adds production value.
However, the direction falters in maintaining consistent pacing and tone. The film struggles to find the right balance between comedy and mystery. I noticed the film shifts abruptly between lighter moments and serious investigative sequences.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The film’s strongest elements include Diljit Dosanjh’s engaging performance and some genuinely amusing moments. The Budapest setting provides an interesting backdrop that differentiates it from typical Bollywood murder mysteries. A few comedic sequences work well, particularly those involving Sherdil’s unconventional detective methods.
However, the weaknesses significantly outweigh the strengths. The script suffers from lack of focus, trying to juggle too many plot elements. The mystery isn’t compelling enough to sustain interest, and I felt the resolution was forced rather than earned.
Critical Reception and Ratings
The film has received mixed to negative reviews from critics and audiences. Bollywood Hungama concluded that Detective Sherdil fails to entice due to faulty script and silly developments. The Times of India gave it 2.5 stars out of 5, noting that the film tries to be a clever caper but ends up being just a colorful distraction.
The Hollywood Reporter India stated that the detective drama wastes Diljit Dosanjh’s screen presence and comic timing. The Indian Express awarded it just 1.5 stars out of 5. IMDb users have rated the film 5.8 out of 10, indicating mediocre audience reception.
Final Verdict
Detective Sherdil represents a missed opportunity to create an engaging murder mystery with comedic elements. While Diljit Dosanjh’s performance and the film’s visual presentation provide some entertainment value, the weak script and unfocused direction prevent it from achieving its potential. The film might appeal to die-hard fans of Diljit Dosanjh, but it’s unlikely to satisfy viewers looking for a well-crafted mystery.
I believe the movie serves as a reminder that even with talented actors and attractive locations, a film needs solid writing and direction to succeed. Detective Sherdil falls short of being the clever caper it aspires to be.
Rating: 2.5/5
